VFYW Contest: Déjà View

For contest #258, we accidentally return to the same hotel from nine years ago.

(Note to sleuthers: the comments section at the bottom of this post is open, if you’d like to share details from your own entry or connect with other sleuthers.)

A reader titles his entry, “Well, sh!t”:

I Google Mapped all around the Great Lakes, Long Island Sound, and Chesapeake Bay. Couldn’t find it. Deceivingly difficult one, this. I’m particularly dis…